Reading a few of the trackbacks at “Mena’s request for feedback on licensing (Commendable attempt to gather feedback but it will only produce more biased results)”:http://www.sixapart.com/log/2004/05/how_are_you_usi.shtml, I am quite stunned at how many blogs people run. “I’m running 27 non-profit personal blogs with 43 authors each all about Brittany Spears” (or something. Where do people find the time. I’ve had up to three blogs running concurrently, but the others always die and I only really count this one as currently active.
The problem with the MovableType license is not really price; there is a free version after all. It is the limitations imposed. Suddenly, MT has gone from being a very flexible tool, inspiring creativity to one with a limitation that if you want to be more creative you will incur a financial penalty for doing so.
Limitations on the use of a product will only stifle use of the product and in the case of weblog, it will stifle creativity and lead to users finding alternative products to do what they want.
Derek Powazek explains how he runs his very popular creative weblogs
bq.:http://www.powazek.com/2004/05/000405.html Similar story [to Fray] on City Stories. There are two blogs, one public and one private, and a ton of authors. 30 at last count. Again, it’s central to the concept of the site to have a lot of authors. That’s why I chose Movable Type to power it.
If someone was using the personal license and was at it’s limit, and had a crazy idea for a new weblog would they really bother to start it up if it was going to cost them extra money to do so? Or would they put it on the shelf for another day? Or would you instead start it using different weblog software to see if it popular? And if it works, would you bother changing it back?
I had an idea for a multi-author story weblog where all the authors were me. Is that one author or five? How could I prove it was all me to the licensing police? The idea was that you weren’t supposed to know I was writing it all, in fact you weren’t supposed to know which author wrote which post, and you were supposed to work it out. The free MT license covers me currently, but I would have had to pay $70 to set that idea up. I wouldn’t have paid for this pie-in-the-sky idea. I was too lazy to get it off the ground anyway, but that’s another story.