There are a some plus points to using “SharpReader”:http://www.hutteman.com/weblog/2003/04/06.html#000056 (which “I installed a few days ago”:http://www.dellah.com/orient/2003/04/08/sharpreader.shtml), but the poorness of the navigation lets it down somewhat. I’m hoping that might be because of the newness of the product, and they might be addressed in a future version.
The most important problem is the inability to go to the next unread entry with a single key press (usually space in most applications). Whilst deleting a feed entry takes you to the next entry automatically, this reduces the usefulness of SharpReader’s best feature; the threading of articles. If you delete the articles, then they don’t link together. If you don’t delete them, you don’t have an easy way of navigating.
I also like the hierarchical folder navigation you can set up, so you can group feeds together (the refresh settings work well here too although I didn’t realise this until after I’d changed the feeds individually from the default). Sadly, the poor navigation lets it down again. Even if you group feeds together, the variety of timestamps from the feeds means that your unread entries are all over the place, leaving you to scroll to find them.
The filter is useful as a search tool, but not much else. Again, there needs to be more options such as Unread articles only, or time based filters.
The threading of articles would be so much better if it could leave the box. It only links together feeds you are subscribed to. How much better would it be if it showed feeds you weren’t subscribed to?
Maybe I’m a little harsh on the product as it is quite new, but has to be compared against established applications such as “Agent”:http://www.forteinc.com/agent/index.php which has the advanced filtering and navigation.
If SharpReader had the proper navigation I would definitely use it for the threading feature, but I need it to get the basics right first. If I have to use my mouse, then I will stay with “Amphetadesk”:http://www.disobey.com/amphetadesk/